Poor drafting of agreements
Large sums of money can hinge on the interpretation of a very few words, which is why professional drafting of agreements is so important. That point was powerfully made in a High Court case concerning an option to purchase a commercial property.
In Helix 3D Limited v Dunedin Industrial Property Nominee Limited & Anr, the tenant of the property had paid £25,000 for the five-year option. It enabled the tenant to purchase the freehold for a fixed price of £1.5 million at any time during the first two years of the agreement.
In the following three years, the price payable was £1.5 million or the open market value, whichever was the greater.
In the fifth year of the option, shortly before it expired, the tenant purported to exercise it by offering £1.5 million and paying a £90,000 deposit. The landlord denied that the option had been validly exercised on the basis that there had been no agreement or determination of the open market value.
In ruling on the dispute, the Court noted that it was rooted in the poor drafting of the agreement. The landlord’s interpretation of the option was divorced from reality in that it would require the tenant to guess the open market value before seeking to exercise it. A reasonable person would not have expected the option to be modelled on a lottery. In finding that the option had been validly exercised, the Court concluded that the tenant’s interpretation made greater commercial sense.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
We're expanding our collaborative mission by launching DB Intelligence, an exclusive market research advisory panel. Built environment professionals can now get paid to share their expertise on industry trends, products and services.
Panel members receive direct financial incentives for participating in research projects like short surveys, 1-2-1 interviews and focus groups. Register today to shape the future of the construction sector.
Planning condition discharge in England and Wales
A brief exoplanation from a building compliance expert, with further links.
Overheating guidance and tools for building designers
Guidance for dealing with element of building fabric control that have increasing importance.
Shading for housing, a design guide
From the Good Homes Alliance and British Blind and Shutter Association.
UK Standard Skills Classification (SSC)
A shared framework for describing skills needs.
Social media ban consultation comes to close
CIOB urges UK Government to consider social media’s role in careers guidance in ban debate.
The latest of eight Skills England apprenticeship units
The addition of battery manufacturing welcomed by ECA with a warning about the risks of fast-tracked apprenticeship units.
Building Control Independent Panel final report
A precis of a key report led by Dame Hackitt with full recommendations and link to the government response.
Building Safety recap April, 2026
A short and longer run-through of the month, with links to further information and sources.
CIAT May 2026 briefing.
From medieval scribes to modern word art.
ECA welcomes crackdown on late payment and push for clean energy, whilst CIOB seek fixed cladding removal timeframes.
Cyber Security in the Built Environment
Protecting projects, data, and digital assets: A CIOB Academy TIS.
Managing competence in the built environment
ITFG publishes new industry guide on how to meet the ICC principles.
The UK's campaign to reduce noise pollution: Mythbusting, articles and topic guides.